For certain cardiac conditions relief may be obtained by extra-cardiac operations, as, for instance, by sympathetic nerve section in cases of angina pectoris or hypertension or by thyroidectomy in cases of heart disease caused by thvrotoxicosis. Improvements in technique in surgery and in anassthesia have, however, made operations on the heart itself a commonplace of modern treat¬ment.
SURGERY IN RELATION TO CONGENITAL HEART DISEASE
It is usually the family doctor or the school medical officer who first makes the diagnosis of a congenital cardiac abnormality. A full examination is then made in hospital to define the nature of the lesion and to assess its suitability for surgical operation. In the application of surgery to the relief of congenital heart disease remarkable advances have been made. New methods are constantly being explored and the combined resources of the biochemist, the physician and the surgeon are now employed as a routine.
In general the risks associated with operative surgery are directly propor¬tional to the extent of the structural defect, and inversely proportional to the judgment, experience and skill of those responsible for the patient. Thus simple ligation of a patent ductus arteriosus by a surgeon who is technically competent in this field, carries a mortality no higher than that of appendicectomy. On the other hand, where the structural defects are numerous and complex the risk is correspondingly increased. Inevitably the mortality is high—even in the hands of an experienced team in a well equipped department. Nevertheless operation may be justifiable because, without such treatment, the prognosis of a particular lesion mav be uniformly grave.
Operations on the heart may be classified roughly into three groups. First and simplest are those which necessitate only thoracotomy without actual operation on the heart. Into this category come ligation of the patent ductus and resection of coarctation of the aorta, as well as those cases of Pallet's Tetralogy in which an anastomosis is made between a subclavian artery and a branch of the pulmonary artery. The hazard in these is generally slight, provided always that the surgeon is experienced in this branch of surgery, that he has the assis¬tance of a competent anaesthetist, a well-trained nursing team and provided that the pre-operative diagnosis is accurate.
In the second group where repair of a septal defect or division of a stenosed pulmonary valve under direct vision is in question, the problems are more formidable. For a time hypothermia was the method of choice, whereby the patient is chilled to a predetermined temperature around 30° C. (86° F.) and after occlusion of the great veins, pulmonary artery and aorta, the heart is arrested by injection of potassium or neostigmine. This allows the surgeon, for example, to open the right atrium and explore and deal with a septal defect. In general, cardiac arrest for several minutes under these hypothermic conditions is harmless because the vital cerebral functions are protected by the low body temperature.
The increasing safety of cardio-pulmonary by-pass techniques, using a heart-lung pump, has led to wide adoption of this method even for closure of simple atrial septal defects. This method is essential in cases involving ven¬tricular septal defects and in all complex malformations. It demands not only costly and complicated apparatus but a highly trained team, not of surgeons only but of technicians, biochemists and blood coagulation specialists. The early high overall mortality, up to 20 per cent., has fallen dramatically to a quarter of that figure in the last few years and to a very low level in the simpler procedures (e.g. closure of atrial septal defects).
The justification for undertaking such operations is the poor prognosis in patients left untreated. It should be borne in mind that complete well-being and lack of limitation of effort in a child, the subject of congenital heart disease, are no sure guides to his future progress. From what is known of the natural history of the different lesions one may predict with some accuracy the probable outcome in individual cases. Thus, for example, children who have a patent ductus arteriosus are continually subject to the hazard of a superimposed subacute bacterial endarteritis—a condition difficult of diagnosis and fatal if untreated which gravely increases the risk of operation. Moreover, those who escape such infection are very liable to develop irreversible cardiac failure in early middle life, by which time operation becomes extremely hazardous. Again, the subjects of atrial septal defect are rarely handicapped in childhood or early adult life, but a large proportion develop cardiac failure in their twenties or early thirties and operation at this stage is much more serious than in the young subject as yet free from pulmonary hypertension. The same considera¬tions apply to patients with coarctation of the aorta, a condition compatible with full activity for many years but which in time leads to the inexorable conse¬quences of sustained gross hypertension with the risk of aortic rupture, cerebral haemorrhage, and left ventricular failure. Hence operation is advisable in the young subject.
In some congenital lesions operation has to be undertaken for the relief of symptoms. For example, in Fallot's Tetralogy the handicap may be such that the child is confined to the house, unable to undertake ordinary activities or to attend school: operation may restore a considerable measure of activity. Again, in cases of severe pulmonary stenosis, in which the right ventricular pressure is extremely high and the muscle grossly hypertrophied, many patients suffer syncopal attacks and there is a constant risk of sudden death on exertion: in these patients also operation has to be undertaken at an early stage. Finally, while operations on very young children are not as yet widely practised, there are certain conditions which lead to progressive cardiac failure at an early age, even in infancy. Among these are occasional cases of coarctation of the aorta of great severity and some cases of patent ductus arteriosus with a large shunt and ;
raised pulmonary blood pressure. Operations for both these conditions hav^ been carried out successfully in infants a few weeks old.
Not every child, the subject of congenital heart disease, is suitable for surgical treatment. A considerable proportion of those deeply cyanosed in early infancy have highly complex malformations irremediable by present methods. For
example, attempts at correction of transposition of the great vessels have been disappointing and there is a number of other conditions (tricuspid atresia, common truncus, etc.) for which treatment at present is impracticable, even with the most skilled surgeon and the most complex equipment. It is appropriate, therefore, to consider some of the common lesions and the indications and risks of their surgical correction.
Patent Ductus Arteriosus.—In patients with uncomplicated patent ductus —usually recognized in early childhood or when the child is examined on first going to school—operation carries a low mortality. It is advisable, preferably between the ages of four and six, in view of the risk of subacute bacterial endar-teritis and of intractable cardiac failure developing in later life. As noted above, occasional cases accompanied by cardiac failure in infancy may have to be operated on at a very early age.
Coarctatlon of the Aorta.—This lesion notoriously shortens life. Opera¬tions for its relief are safest when carried out in childhood or before puberty.' When performed after the age of twenty they are more hazardous and particularly so after the age of thirty. The rising mortality is associated with the progressive arterial degeneration of increasing age. The mortality of operation in skilled hands is low and the results are good. Untreated, these patients are in peril during strenuous activity, and in women during labour, from the risk of aortic rupture, cerebral hasmorrhage and left ventricular failure. On the other hand, if a patient over the age of thirty is found by chance to have coarctation of the aorta and is symptom-free he is best left untreated.
Atrial Septal Defect.—Defects in the atrial septum are common and vary in position and size. The common defect high in the septum (ostium secundum) may be large and may lead to an enormous increase in the pulmonary blood flow, which in turn puts a strain on the right heart and leads to pulmonary vascular changes. Such patients commonly develop symptoms in their twenties and soon develop failure. Operation in skilled hands carries a low mortality, but calls for either the induction of hypothermia and a short cardiac arrest or for cardio-pulmonary by-pass. Before operation is undertaken in patients with an atrial septal defect it is most important that a precise diagnosis be reached, including an estimation of the magnitude of the shunt, the state of the pulmonary vessels, and in particular the site of the defect. Defects low in the septum (ostium primum) are commonly associated with defects of mitral and tricuspid leaflets and with free communications between the two atria and between the two ventricles. Correction of this defect is hazardous and demands assisted circu¬lation from a cardio-pulmonary by-pass pump. A serious operative hazard is permanent complete heart block from an ill placed stitch.
Pulmonary Stenosis.—There is wide variation in the severity of this lesion. Many children with pulmonary stenosis have a loud murmur, little disability and little upset in cardiac haemodynamics. In others the stenosis is extreme, the right ventricular pressure very high and the right ventricular muscle grossly hypertrophied. Operation is not indicated in every case and many people with slighter degrees of pulmonary valvular stenosis may live to an old age with little handicap. On the other hand those with severe stenosis are generally short¬lived. The decision to operate should be reached only after careful assessment of the individual case, utilizing ancillary methods of investigation (cardiac catheterization, etc.)
Operations of two types are practised for its relief. The original method was a blind transventricular section of the valve, yielding reasonably good results but in some respects unsatisfactory. Today the stenosed valve is divided under direct vision through the opened pulmonary artery under hypothermia or with the heart-lung pump. The operative risk is not great and the results excellent.
Aortic Stenosis.—Similar considerations apply to this lesion as to pulmonary stenosis. All grades of severity occur from slight to severe and operation is indicated only in a proportion of cases. The original operations were performed by a blind transventricular valvotomy, but today it is preferable to operate under direct vision through the opened aorta. Such operations on the left heart demand a cardio-pulmonary by-pass.
Ventricular Septal Defect.—In this lesion all grades of severity occur from the classical Maladie de Roger with a tiny orifice high in the septum to patients with a gross defect several centimetres in diameter. Contrary to general medical belief ventricular septal defect is not a benign lesion, and only the smallest defects are compatible with a long unhampered life. Larger defects lead to gross pulmonary plethora, to a rising pulmonary blood pressure and to early failure and death. Repair of lesions of any but minimal size is therefore justifiable in view of the bad prognosis which they carry. Such operations demand the full resources of cardio-pulmonary by-pass techniques and a skilled and experienced team. Detailed pre-operative investigation by cardiac catheterization, etc., .is essential.
Fallot's Tetralogy.—This syndrome is of great importance on two counts :. first, its frequency, and secondly, the severity of the handicap it imposes. It constitutes a high proportion of all cases of cyanotic congenital heart disease surviving into later childhood and early adult life, and in fact some two-thirds of such children have this particular combination of lesions. A much smaller proportion of very young cardiac patients have Fallot's Tetralogy since many cyanosed infants have lesions of other types which in the majority are incom¬patible with prolonged survival. The frequency of this tetralogy in later childhood and adolescence is so great, and its susceptibility to treatment so striking, that every cyanosed child with congenital heart disease should be reviewed with this diagnosis in mind. This entails detailed investigation in a specialized clinic.
Various operations have been practised for relief of the condition. The original operation devised by Blalock—anastomosis of one subclavian artery to the corresponding branch of the pulmonary artery—gave relief from cyanosis and remarkable increase, in effort tolerance to a large number of handicapped children. A similar procedure is Pott's operation, in which a small fenestration is made between the aorta and the pulmonary artery in the form of an artificial ductus. The mortality from these operations is not high and the relief afforded is considerable. The objection to both these operations is that they are simply palliative : they give relief by increasing the blood flow to the lungs but do not correct the other deformities of the tetralogy—the pulmonary stenosis, the ventricular septal defect and over-riding aorta. Accordingly other operations have been devised in an attempt to cure the whole syndrome—division of the stenosed pulmonary valve, and closure of the ventricular septal defect. These demand the by-pass technique described above for cases of ventricular septal defect, while the stenosed pulmonary valve may be divided. These procedures carry a considerably higher mortality than the simple operations first practised, but when successful are believed to be more satis¬factory. Whether the improved results are sufficient to counterbalance the increased risk is a matter of some debate.
Other Congenital Cardiac Lesions.—Of the other congenital lesions many are extremely complicated and few are at present amenable to surgical correction. For example, transposition of the great vessels, in which the aorta rises from the right ventricle and the pulmonary artery from the left, has been tackled by attempts to transplant the two venae cavae and the four pulmonary veins to the respective venous and arterial atria. These operations are in general disappointing and the mortality prohibitive. Similarly operations for tricuspid atresia, common truncus, and comparable malformations are at present beyond the scope of surgery.
TETANUS
16 years ago